top of page

MARIAH CAREY

3

1990–2018

1148 reviews

20 albums

OVERVIEW

OVERVIEW

Caution

4.1

warm reception

unified reaction

28 reviews →

2025

Here for It All

3.5

warm reception

unified reaction

17 reviews →

REVIEW

REVIEW

Butterfly

2

2/5

York, UK

September 30, 1997

She could make the blues beige.

Butterfly

3

3

Jerusalem, Israel

September 30, 1997

Butterfly

2

C

3

Jacksonville, FL, USA

October 1, 1997

On her latest album, Carey doesn't have one song that can match up to the songwriting skills she displayed on her last album, 1995's "Daydream."

Butterfly

1

1/4

3

Boston, MA, USA

October 3, 1997

Other than her towering aria in “Breakdown” there’s hardly one moment at which Carey's singing demands attention.

Butterfly

4

3/4

3

Wichita Falls, TX, USA

October 3, 1997

Mariah expresses changes in her life—musically and personally—by updating her image and sound, while being sure to not fix anything that wasn't broken.

Butterfly

3

3

Newport News, VA, USA

October 3, 1997

She's less sure-footed on the hip-hop tunes, sometimes giving ground to her guest artists.

Butterfly

2

4/10

3

October 4, 1997

James Oldham

Butterfly

1

1/5

3

Melbourne VIC, Australia

October 5, 1997

One suspects that if Carey's career continues in its present direction that's what it's most likely to do – fly away.

Butterfly

3

3/5

3

Vancouver, BC, Canada

October 11, 1997

Katherine Monk

Butterfly

4

3

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

October 12, 1997

All in all it's a more mature Mariah this time round. But don't worry, her trademark vocal gymnastics are still as prominent as ever.

BIRD'S EYE VIEW

BIRD'S EYE VIEW

October 9, 2024

What the Critics Said About Mariah Carey's 1991

October 8, 2024

What the Critics Said About Mariah Carey's 1990 Debut Album and How it Changed Over

bottom of page