top of page

MARIAH CAREY

3

1990–2018

1148 reviews

20 albums

OVERVIEW

OVERVIEW

Caution

4.1

warm reception

unified reaction

28 reviews →

2025

Here for It All

3.5

warm reception

unified reaction

17 reviews →

REVIEW

REVIEW

Butterfly

3

3/5

Peterborough, UK

September 25, 1997

We all know she's got a voice that could shatter Cathedral's windows, it's just a lack of variety that lets her down time and time again.

Butterfly

3

2/4

3

Dayton, OH, USA

September 26, 1997

Butterfly

1

3

September 26, 1997

Joe Jackson

Butterfly

3

2.5/5

3

Knoxville, TN, USA

September 26, 1997

Butterfly

4

3.5/4

3

Pittsburgh, PA, USA

September 26, 1997

Tony Norman

Butterfly

4

4/5

3

Columbia, SC, USA

September 26, 1997

Jerry McCormick

Butterfly

3

3/5

3

Winnipeg, MB, Canada

September 26, 1997

John Kendle

Butterfly

4

3

Allentown, PA, USA

September 27, 1997

Paul Willistein

Butterfly

3

2.5/4

3

Springfield, MO, USA

September 28, 1997

Mark Marymont

Butterfly

4

3

New York, NY, USA

September 29, 1997

If you never thought of her as human before, "Butterfly" will change your mind. Prick her and she bleeds.

BIRD'S EYE VIEW

BIRD'S EYE VIEW

October 9, 2024

What the Critics Said About Mariah Carey's 1991

October 8, 2024

What the Critics Said About Mariah Carey's 1990 Debut Album and How it Changed Over

bottom of page