CRITICARCHIVE

Two usually excruciating, sickly sweet ingredients - Mariah Carey's chirpy singing and a Christmas album - somehow complement each other perfectly.

November 20, 1998

June 18, 1999

August 25, 2000

September 22, 2000

Two usually excruciating, sickly sweet ingredients - Mariah Carey's chirpy singing and a Christmas album - somehow complement each other perfectly.

October 19, 2001

May 14, 2004

Two usually excruciating, sickly sweet ingredients - Mariah Carey's chirpy singing and a Christmas album - somehow complement each other perfectly.

April 22, 2005

Two usually excruciating, sickly sweet ingredients - Mariah Carey's chirpy singing and a Christmas album - somehow complement each other perfectly.

October 23, 2009