top of page
Fiona Shepherd

♬
Charmbracelet
Edinburgh, UK
Whether Carey's traumas were massive or minor is, in a sense, irrelevant, since she's translated them into an album that, even by her glossy and aerated standards, is trite beyond the call of duty.
December 6, 2002

♬
Emancipation of Mimi
"Mine Again" and "Fly Like a Bird" both have that juicy 1970s smooch factor, but the rest of the album is a flimsy forum for the usual Mariah wittering and twittering.
2/5
April 8, 2005
35
